RBSL Forums

Legacy (RBSL) => Hard Cap/Waivers (RBSL) => Topic started by: BlazersGM on February 25, 2013, 02:30:51 AM



Title: Hard Cap Violation - Toronto Raptors - Derrick Williams
Post by: BlazersGM on February 25, 2013, 02:30:51 AM
Per Lou's orders.

1.   Sacramento Kings - Passed.
2.   Philadelphia 76ers
3.   Cleveland Cavaliers
4.   Los Angeles Lakers
5.   Miami Heat
6.   Brooklyn Nets
7.   Oklahoma City Thunder 
8.   Utah Jazz
9.   Indiana Pacers
10.   Washington Wizards
11.   Denver Nuggets
12.   Dallas Mavericks
13.   Portland Trailblazers
14.   New York Knicks
15.   Minnesota Timberwolves
16.   Detroit Pistons
17.   San Antonio Spurs
18.   Boston Celtics
19.   New Orleans Hornets
20.   Los Angeles Clippers
21.   Milwaukee Bucks
22.   Orlando Magic
23.   Chicago Bulls
24.   Golden State Warriors
25.   Houston Rockets
26.   Phoenix Suns
27.   Memphis Grizzlies
28.   Atlanta Hawks


Remember the Rules
1. Once a hard cap violation has been identified, the commish will post a complete waiver list order and a time limit (i.e., 48 hours)
2. Any team who wants Player X should put a claim in to the commish via PM
3. At the end of the 48 hours, the commish looks at all of the teams who put in a claim and Player X gets assigned to the team who's highest on the priority rank.
4. If nobody claims Player X, then repeat steps 1-3 with Player Y (next highest scorer).
5. Should the violating team trade their way out of the hard cap violation prior to ANY claim for the player in question, the trade will be procesed and waiver process ended - the commish will simply look for time stamps of the trade being accepted trades and the waiver claim and process the transaction accordingly

- players claimed off waivers have no trade restrictions

- you cannot claim someone off waivers if his salary will put you over the hard cap


Title: Re: Hard Cap Violation - Toronto Raptors - Derrick Williams
Post by: OldKingsGM2 on February 25, 2013, 06:03:15 AM
I have to pass, he'll put me over the hard cap.


Title: Re: Hard Cap Violation - Toronto Raptors - Derrick Williams
Post by: AsstRapsGM on February 25, 2013, 11:28:51 AM
I have to pass, he'll put me over the hard cap.
That shouldn't be the only reason anyone would pass :P


Title: Re: Hard Cap Violation - Toronto Raptors - Derrick Williams
Post by: SpiritGM on February 25, 2013, 02:11:51 PM
Just out of curiosity - what if no one claims the big money players on Raps?


Title: Re: Hard Cap Violation - Toronto Raptors - Derrick Williams
Post by: MagicGM on February 25, 2013, 02:17:13 PM
Then we keep taking smaller players until he's under.


Title: Re: Hard Cap Violation - Toronto Raptors - Derrick Williams
Post by: SpiritGM on February 25, 2013, 02:18:09 PM
May take a while then LOL


Title: Re: Hard Cap Violation - Toronto Raptors - Derrick Williams
Post by: AsstRapsGM on February 25, 2013, 03:43:15 PM
May take a while then LOL
yup might take his whole team lol


Title: Re: Hard Cap Violation - Toronto Raptors - Derrick Williams
Post by: BlazersGM on February 26, 2013, 01:38:35 AM
76ers are up.


Title: Re: Hard Cap Violation - Toronto Raptors - Derrick Williams
Post by: AsstRapsGM on February 26, 2013, 01:43:03 AM
76ers are up.
its a pm dude

48 hours


Title: Re: Hard Cap Violation - Toronto Raptors - Derrick Williams
Post by: BlazersGM on February 26, 2013, 01:52:31 AM

lawl herp. I think the Kings saying they passed threw me off.


Title: Re: Hard Cap Violation - Toronto Raptors - Derrick Williams
Post by: OldNuggetsGM on February 26, 2013, 08:54:43 AM
Then we keep taking smaller players until he's under.
are you sure? in the rules i can't find a term that it will be processed till he is under the hard cap.
in fact:
You may be over the cap in between sims or the offseason. But if you are over the cap while a game is simmed, that is when you are hit with the penalty.
- Penalty: you will lose your team's leading scorer from the previous season. Whoever had the most PPG last season, whether playing for you or acquired later during a trade. He will be placed on waivers. The team who claims the individual off waivers must pay the full contract amount owed to the player; the team who loses the player pays no salary.

i always thought loosing the best player is penalty enough. loosing the whole team is too much imo.


Title: Re: Hard Cap Violation - Toronto Raptors - Derrick Williams
Post by: MagicGM on February 26, 2013, 09:50:55 AM
If no one claims his "best" player because his contract is so ridiculous, it goes to the next guy.

He cut $40 million in players, that's why he's in this situation.

Players will continue to be claimed until he's under the hard cap. There's really no other solution.


Title: Re: Hard Cap Violation - Toronto Raptors - Derrick Williams
Post by: AsstRapsGM on February 26, 2013, 10:04:45 AM

Remember the Rules
1. Once a hard cap violation has been identified, the commish will post a complete waiver list order and a time limit (i.e., 48 hours)
2. Any team who wants Player X should put a claim in to the commish via PM
3. At the end of the 48 hours, the commish looks at all of the teams who put in a claim and Player X gets assigned to the team who's highest on the priority rank.
4. If nobody claims Player X, then repeat steps 1-3 with Player Y (next highest scorer).
5. Should the violating team trade their way out of the hard cap violation prior to ANY claim for the player in question, the trade will be procesed and waiver process ended - the commish will simply look for time stamps of the trade being accepted trades and the waiver claim and process the transaction a


Title: Re: Hard Cap Violation - Toronto Raptors - Derrick Williams
Post by: OldNuggetsGM on February 26, 2013, 10:11:07 AM

Remember the Rules
1. Once a hard cap violation has been identified, the commish will post a complete waiver list order and a time limit (i.e., 48 hours)
2. Any team who wants Player X should put a claim in to the commish via PM
3. At the end of the 48 hours, the commish looks at all of the teams who put in a claim and Player X gets assigned to the team who's highest on the priority rank.
4. If nobody claims Player X, then repeat steps 1-3 with Player Y (next highest scorer).
5. Should the violating team trade their way out of the hard cap violation prior to ANY claim for the player in question, the trade will be procesed and waiver process ended - the commish will simply look for time stamps of the trade being accepted trades and the waiver claim and process the transaction a

step 4 is clear to me but it is still mentioned 1 player taken from the team. it is never stated that the process will continue till he is under the hard cap.


Title: Re: Hard Cap Violation - Toronto Raptors - Derrick Williams
Post by: MagicGM on February 26, 2013, 10:13:44 AM
Well if he's still over the hard cap after another sim there's another violation.

He cut over 40 million dollars in players and his "best" player no one wants.


Title: Re: Hard Cap Violation - Toronto Raptors - Derrick Williams
Post by: OldNuggetsGM on February 26, 2013, 10:14:37 AM
If no one claims his "best" player because his contract is so ridiculous, it goes to the next guy.

He cut $40 million in players, that's why he's in this situation.

Players will continue to be claimed until he's under the hard cap. There's really no other solution.
why is there no other solution? i understand that you have to pay a penalty for being over but i don't udnerstand that it has to be done till he is under the hardcap. i always thought after paying the penalty it is ok to be over.


Title: Re: Hard Cap Violation - Toronto Raptors - Derrick Williams
Post by: AsstRapsGM on February 26, 2013, 10:26:12 AM

Remember the Rules
1. Once a hard cap violation has been identified, the commish will post a complete waiver list order and a time limit (i.e., 48 hours)
2. Any team who wants Player X should put a claim in to the commish via PM
3. At the end of the 48 hours, the commish looks at all of the teams who put in a claim and Player X gets assigned to the team who's highest on the priority rank.
4. If nobody claims Player X, then repeat steps 1-3 with Player Y (next highest scorer).
5. Should the violating team trade their way out of the hard cap violation prior to ANY claim for the player in question, the trade will be procesed and waiver process ended - the commish will simply look for time stamps of the trade being accepted trades and the waiver claim and process the transaction a


step 4 is clear to me but it is still mentioned 1 player taken from the team. it is never stated that the process will continue till he is under the hard cap.

Ok.. Except then if I want my leading scorer out, I'll just sign 5 other max players, have a salary of 100+ mil, and once my leading scorer is gone I still get to keep the rest? umm no.


Title: Re: Hard Cap Violation - Toronto Raptors - Derrick Williams
Post by: OldNuggetsGM on February 26, 2013, 11:06:11 AM

Remember the Rules
1. Once a hard cap violation has been identified, the commish will post a complete waiver list order and a time limit (i.e., 48 hours)
2. Any team who wants Player X should put a claim in to the commish via PM
3. At the end of the 48 hours, the commish looks at all of the teams who put in a claim and Player X gets assigned to the team who's highest on the priority rank.
4. If nobody claims Player X, then repeat steps 1-3 with Player Y (next highest scorer).
5. Should the violating team trade their way out of the hard cap violation prior to ANY claim for the player in question, the trade will be procesed and waiver process ended - the commish will simply look for time stamps of the trade being accepted trades and the waiver claim and process the transaction a


step 4 is clear to me but it is still mentioned 1 player taken from the team. it is never stated that the process will continue till he is under the hard cap.

Ok.. Except then if I want my leading scorer out, I'll just sign 5 other max players, have a salary of 100+ mil, and once my leading scorer is gone I still get to keep the rest? umm no.
i don't think your scenario can be done. as far as i know you will loose every FA that was signed while being over the hard cap. and the current hardcap violation is a different story imo. in fact if no one clains his biggest 2 salarys he has to loose at least 4 guys to get under which force him to sign 1 FA to get to the minimum required which will send him back over the hardcap..


Title: Re: Hard Cap Violation - Toronto Raptors - Derrick Williams
Post by: AsstRapsGM on February 26, 2013, 11:37:54 AM

Remember the Rules
1. Once a hard cap violation has been identified, the commish will post a complete waiver list order and a time limit (i.e., 48 hours)
2. Any team who wants Player X should put a claim in to the commish via PM
3. At the end of the 48 hours, the commish looks at all of the teams who put in a claim and Player X gets assigned to the team who's highest on the priority rank.
4. If nobody claims Player X, then repeat steps 1-3 with Player Y (next highest scorer).
5. Should the violating team trade their way out of the hard cap violation prior to ANY claim for the player in question, the trade will be procesed and waiver process ended - the commish will simply look for time stamps of the trade being accepted trades and the waiver claim and process the transaction a


step 4 is clear to me but it is still mentioned 1 player taken from the team. it is never stated that the process will continue till he is under the hard cap.

Ok.. Except then if I want my leading scorer out, I'll just sign 5 other max players, have a salary of 100+ mil, and once my leading scorer is gone I still get to keep the rest? umm no.
i don't think your scenario can be done. as far as i know you will loose every FA that was signed while being over the hard cap. and the current hardcap violation is a different story imo. in fact if no one clains his biggest 2 salarys he has to loose at least 4 guys to get under which force him to sign 1 FA to get to the minimum required which will send him back over the hardcap..

There is a reason one of these situations hasn't happened since 2009, because the consequences suck. If he didn't want it to happen, then don't sign Jesus Barlow to 1yr 14.4 on day 5 when you are 7 under the cap. Simple.


Title: Re: Hard Cap Violation - Toronto Raptors - Derrick Williams
Post by: BlazersGM on February 26, 2013, 12:01:03 PM
Quite honestly, there's nobody of value on his roster. Since he intentionally went over the cap so he could lose Williams, he should lose his first rounder as a penalty. In circumstances like this, there's no deterrent to go over when there's minimal talent to lose.


Title: Re: Hard Cap Violation - Toronto Raptors - Derrick Williams
Post by: RaptorsGM on February 26, 2013, 12:02:51 PM

Remember the Rules
1. Once a hard cap violation has been identified, the commish will post a complete waiver list order and a time limit (i.e., 48 hours)
2. Any team who wants Player X should put a claim in to the commish via PM
3. At the end of the 48 hours, the commish looks at all of the teams who put in a claim and Player X gets assigned to the team who's highest on the priority rank.
4. If nobody claims Player X, then repeat steps 1-3 with Player Y (next highest scorer).
5. Should the violating team trade their way out of the hard cap violation prior to ANY claim for the player in question, the trade will be procesed and waiver process ended - the commish will simply look for time stamps of the trade being accepted trades and the waiver claim and process the transaction a


step 4 is clear to me but it is still mentioned 1 player taken from the team. it is never stated that the process will continue till he is under the hard cap.

Ok.. Except then if I want my leading scorer out, I'll just sign 5 other max players, have a salary of 100+ mil, and once my leading scorer is gone I still get to keep the rest? umm no.
i don't think your scenario can be done. as far as i know you will loose every FA that was signed while being over the hard cap. and the current hardcap violation is a different story imo. in fact if no one clains his biggest 2 salarys he has to loose at least 4 guys to get under which force him to sign 1 FA to get to the minimum required which will send him back over the hardcap..

There is a reason one of these situations hasn't happened since 2009, because the consequences suck. If he didn't want it to happen, then don't sign Jesus Barlow to 1yr 14.4 on day 5 when you are 7 under the cap. Simple.
First and foremost i had no idea barlow's contract would e that much. Only after that i realized i had that much bird rights for him. As far as i know, he was just a minimum player last year. And there have been instances, i think like one of the max players Cavs had before. He had 10+ years of experience. I sent an offer of 15million, turns out max he could receive was only about 13, iirc. Because his last contract wasnt more than that amount. So i thought it was the same with barlow because there was no way he would have earned more than 7m that on any contract.

2, i was over the cap on day 3 or something. I made a deal with the nuggets to put me below the cap. Around 73, if im not mistaken  So it wasnt like i wasnt trying. Thats before i signed barlow. Thinking i would be at around 79.

After barlow signed, i was 89million over the cap. I even posted a block o trying to get below the cap. I even had a deal with the mavs (phillip for daly. A 17ppg scorer for a bench warmer).. Our initial talks didnt even invlude a tpe. I shouldered that tpe just to put my team at A more Manageable 84 million. Now, i made a block for derrick williams. I must admit, i did get offers, but i dont see the offers as viable options moving forward. Especially if deals includes my 1st round pick this year + williams for expiring deals.

So to say i didnt try to get below the hard cap is ridiculous.


Title: Re: Hard Cap Violation - Toronto Raptors - Derrick Williams
Post by: RaptorsGM on February 26, 2013, 12:04:02 PM
Quite honestly, there's nobody of value on his roster. Since he intentionally went over the cap so he could lose Williams, he should lose his first rounder as a penalty. In circumstances like this, there's no deterrent to go over when there's minimal talent to lose.
Thats too much. Is there a rule regarding this?


Title: Re: Hard Cap Violation - Toronto Raptors - Derrick Williams
Post by: AsstRapsGM on February 26, 2013, 12:14:44 PM
Quite honestly, there's nobody of value on his roster. Since he intentionally went over the cap so he could lose Williams, he should lose his first rounder as a penalty. In circumstances like this, there's no deterrent to go over when there's minimal talent to lose.
Thats too much. Is there a rule regarding this?
I wouldn't do that because it's not a posted rule, but you can be sure I will auction off each player one by one.



Title: Re: Hard Cap Violation - Toronto Raptors - Derrick Williams
Post by: ExPacersGM on February 26, 2013, 12:23:50 PM
How do you not know what youre bidding on a free agent?

Would not allowing transactions that put you over the cap in the first place make things easier? I mean if youre at $73mil and you put in a bid for $14mil, that bid just doesnt go through? Same with trades?


Title: Re: Hard Cap Violation - Toronto Raptors - Derrick Williams
Post by: MagicGM on February 26, 2013, 12:27:35 PM
How do you not know what youre bidding on a free agent?

Would not allowing transactions that put you over the cap in the first place make things easier? I mean if youre at $73mil and you put in a bid for $14mil, that bid just doesnt go through? Same with trades?

The problem with that is I don't know if the program can do it. Lou would know - but I don't know if the program has a "hard cap" protection for signing FAs. And asking Lou to double check each bid is nonsensical.


Title: Re: Hard Cap Violation - Toronto Raptors - Derrick Williams
Post by: RaptorsGM on February 26, 2013, 12:30:18 PM
How do you not know what youre bidding on a free agent?

Would not allowing transactions that put you over the cap in the first place make things easier? I mean if youre at $73mil and you put in a bid for $14mil, that bid just doesnt go through? Same with trades?
I didnt put in 14million. I send max possible. I didnt know 14million is the max possible.



Title: Re: Hard Cap Violation - Toronto Raptors - Derrick Williams
Post by: RaptorsGM on February 26, 2013, 12:31:18 PM
Quite honestly, there's nobody of value on his roster. Since he intentionally went over the cap so he could lose Williams, he should lose his first rounder as a penalty. In circumstances like this, there's no deterrent to go over when there's minimal talent to lose.
Thats too much. Is there a rule regarding this?
I wouldn't do that because it's not a posted rule, but you can be sure I will auction off each player one by one.


Sure. As long as its done in proper process according to the hard cap rule.


Title: Re: Hard Cap Violation - Toronto Raptors - Derrick Williams
Post by: AsstRapsGM on February 26, 2013, 12:36:59 PM
Quite honestly, there's nobody of value on his roster. Since he intentionally went over the cap so he could lose Williams, he should lose his first rounder as a penalty. In circumstances like this, there's no deterrent to go over when there's minimal talent to lose.
Thats too much. Is there a rule regarding this?
I wouldn't do that because it's not a posted rule, but you can be sure I will auction off each player one by one.


Sure. As long as its done in proper process according to the hard cap rule.
Which I promise you I will do.

You could just trade 1 draft pick with Williams and probably get him off your roster immediately, but we all know thats never going to happen.


Title: Re: Hard Cap Violation - Toronto Raptors - Derrick Williams
Post by: OldHeatGM on February 26, 2013, 01:01:45 PM
Can the penalty be that he changes his avatar?


Title: Re: Hard Cap Violation - Toronto Raptors - Derrick Williams
Post by: AsstRapsGM on February 26, 2013, 11:02:52 PM
Washington Wizards claim Derrick Williams